A health questionnaire can ask whether you feel anxious, whether your hair is thinning, whether sex still works. One company that sells treatments for exactly those things promised the process was “100% online, private, and secure”. Seven American states now say that promise was not kept.
What the regulator says happened
The company is Hims & Hers, which sells prescription treatments online for hair loss, weight, anxiety, depression and sexual health. America’s Federal Trade Commission — the body that polices how companies treat customers — sued it in July. On 10 November five more states joined: Arizona, Florida, Nebraska, Ohio and Wisconsin, alongside Utah and California.
The first claim is about the form itself. Hims told customers that their medical records and “sensitive information” would only be seen by the providers treating them. According to the complaint, the site also carried Meta’s tracking tools — a “pixel” is a small piece of code that quietly reports back to Facebook which page you opened, whether you signed up and whether you bought. Through those tools, the regulator says, the company sent Facebook about 8 million reports about people completing a registration or buying a treatment, and those reports disclosed health information.
It also uploaded lists of hundreds of thousands of customer email addresses to Snapchat’s advertising system, so those people could be matched to their Snapchat accounts, the complaint says. Tracking tools from Google, Microsoft, Pinterest, Reddit and TikTok were on the site as well.
The second claim is about money. The FTC says most customers were charged and signed up to a monthly subscription as soon as they sent the form, before any consultation, even though the advertising promised a provider would help them find a treatment that was “right for them”. Cancelling, it says, meant hunting for a button that appeared only after choosing “add/remove items from order” and clicking through several screens.
Hims & Hers denies all of it. In July the company called the claims “baseless”, said the lawsuit ignores nearly three years of evidence it gave the regulator, and said its privacy policy lets customers choose how their data is used. A lawsuit is a set of allegations, not a verdict; a court will decide.

Why it matters to you
Health is the most valuable thing an advertiser can learn about you. A list of people taking antidepressants in one city is worth more than a list of people who like football, because it predicts what you will worry about and what you will pay for.
The second reason is the shape of the page. When a website wants your card before it shows you a doctor, you are not asking a question any more — you are buying. The form is the shop.
And Europe is not a different planet. The same tracking tools sit on European websites, which is why European regulators keep fining companies over health data. In September 2026, Italy’s data protection authority fined a health-analytics company €7 million over a database covering about a million patients that it said was not truly anonymous. What Europe gives you is not immunity. It is rights.
What you can actually do
- Before you type a symptom, scroll to the bottom of the page. If there is no privacy link, or the explanation is one sentence long, close the tab.
- Do not sign in to a health site with Facebook or Google. That button is also a way for the two companies to recognise the same person.
- If a site wants your card before it shows you a doctor, stop. Ask in writing what you will be charged, and when.
- Check what you already pay for. On an iPhone: Settings, your name, Subscriptions. On Android: Play Store, then Payments and subscriptions. Cancel anything you do not recognise.
- Ask a company what it holds about you, and ask it to delete it. In Europe both requests are free, and one email is enough.
- Complain to your country’s data protection authority if the answer is poor. It costs nothing and takes a form online.
- Use a separate email address for health sites, so a leaked list does not connect to your bank, your job and your family.
Common misunderstandings
Myth: a doctor’s website is covered by doctor confidentiality
Confidentiality binds the clinician who treats you, not the website around them. A tracking pixel sits on the page, not inside the consultation. That gap is exactly what this case is about.
Myth: they only see anonymous statistics
A report saying a registration was completed, sent together with an identifier for that person, is not a statistic. European rules treat an identifier that lets someone be singled out as personal data, which is why the Italian case turned on a “persistent identifier”, not a name.
Myth: I have nothing to hide, it is only hair loss
The value is not the hair loss. It is the combination: a thinning hairline, a sleep problem, a weight prescription and a postcode. That picture is what makes a list worth buying, and it is built one harmless answer at a time.
What to watch for next
The case is young: a complaint, an amended complaint, and no trial date announced. The question a judge has to answer is whether a “purchase” report sent to an advertising platform counts as health information. If it does, that reaches every shop that sells medicine, supplements or therapy online.
Watch the quieter signal. When a case like this lands, other telehealth companies tend to remove tracking tools from their checkout pages without announcing it.
In Europe, watch the regulators rather than the courts. Health data is a specially protected category here, and the fines arrive years after the practice starts.
The one thing to remember
A form that asks about your body is a form about your body. Assume anything you type could be read by someone you will never meet, and read the price before you answer the questions.
Image: “Medical teleconsultation” by Ceibos, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
